Quick Greencastle IN MLS Search

Browse All Greencastle IN Properties for Sale

$575,000
3 Beds 2 Baths
Welcome to this one of a kind 18-acre Putnam County homestead! This beautifully updated 3 bedroom 2 bathroom home in Greencastle is quite the gem. Tucked back from 231 down its long lane, there is plenty of peace, quiet, and privacy while still being conveniently located close to town. Be warmly greeted by the covered porch, and wander inside to the wood burning fireplace. The kitchen has been completely remodeled, featuring a brand new double-oven, custom counter tops, and stainless steel appliances. Upstairs is home to a third bedroom and full bathroom. There is also am upper level bonus room that could be utilized as a fourth bedroom, office space, or home gym. The basement has a 1 car garage at the front of the home, and a 2 car garage at the other end of the home. The 1 car bay contains a built-in hookup ready for a generator, and stair access to the kitchen. You will also find a wood stove ready to be connected. Between the two bays sit ample space one could utilize for extra storage, entertainment space, or potentially convert into additional living/bedrooms. The back yard features a partially covered deck and is completely fenced in and family-friendly. An additional storage sheds sits just outside the fence. Across the drive sits the 52'x32' oversized pole barn which is already equipped with utilities. It would make an ideal workshop, garage, or hang out space. Its 8" concrete flooring and 14' bay make a perfect place for working on large equipment. The maturely wooded acreage provides plenty of space & freedom for hunting, trapping, and ATV trail riding. Down the drive, at the rear of the property sits the fully stocked pond with a party dock that has both water and electric run to it. Included are the gas grill, furniture, refrigerator, and paddle boat. Nearby is an operable outhouse with plumbing. There's also a second dock. Forget having to search for the perfect camp spot; it's right in your own back yard, fire pit included! A once in a lifetime find!

662 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle

Listing courtesy of White Stag Realty, LLC.

$179,000
3 Beds 1 Baths
Welcome to 903 Hillcrest Dr, a charming single-family home nestled in a prime location close to downtown Greencastle! This move-in ready gem offers 936 square feet of living space, featuring 3 cozy bedrooms and 1 full bathroom. Built in 1955, this home has retained its classic appeal with original hardwood floors throughout the living room and all bedrooms, adding warmth and character to the space. The covered front porch welcomes you into a bright and inviting living area, perfect for relaxing or entertaining guests. The detached 1-car garage provides ample room for parking, with additional space for storage, a workshop, or whatever suits your needs. Step outside to discover a huge backyard that offers endless possibilities! Whether you dream of setting up a fire pit, building a mini barn, or creating a large deck for outdoor gatherings, this spacious yard can accommodate it all. The home is further enhanced with a newer roof, siding, and windows-all approximately 6 years old-ensuring peace of mind for years to come. Located just moments away from downtown Greencastle, you'll have easy access to local shops, dining, DePauw University, and various parks and community events. This property is perfect for first-time homebuyers, retirees, or families looking for an affordable home that is comfortable now but also offers opportunities to customize and improve over time. Don't miss out on this opportunity to own a piece of Greencastle charm with unbeatable convenience and potential!

903 Hillcrest Drive, Greencastle

Listing courtesy of Mark Dietel Realty, LLC.

$169,900
2 Beds 2 Baths
Gorgeous turn-key condo located in historic Spring Tree Square, downtown Greencastle. This freshly painted end unit featuring large windows, private balcony and cathedral ceilings is ready for your personal touches. Foyer with original terrazzo flooring leads to the large living room which is filled with light. Enjoy your morning coffee while relaxing on the private balcony overlooking a quiet tree lined street. Adjacent kitchen and dining area has all new stainless steel appliances, breakfast bar and pantry. This flexible space could also accommodate a home office, library or craft/hobby area. Primary bedroom has a full bath with shower, grab bars, heat lamp and walk in closet where you will find the laundry and as well as the pull down stairs to the large attic perfect for storing all of your seasonal decorations and other keepsakes. Second full bath off of the hallway has bathtub/shower combo. Garage parking includes one space and elevator so no stairs are required. HOA fee include water, sewer and trash as well as all maintenance of exterior and common areas, meeting room, community library, and inside mailboxes. A guest suite is also available in the building. Experience all that Greencastle has to offer within easy walking distance of DePauw campus, downtown shops, movie theatre, restaurants, the public library, Robe-Ann Park and upcoming Vine Street corridor.

111 S Spring Street, Greencastle

Listing courtesy of Prime Real Estate ERA Powered.

$599,900
5 Beds 2 Baths
Step into this gorgeous retreat that blends modern upgrades with classic mid-century architecture. Nestled along Big Walnut Creek & an 1880's covered bridge, the property features a charming two-story barn surrounded by woods, creating a serene backdrop. Convenience of high speed internet make working remotely from this tranquil oasis a breeze. 2 miles from downtown Greencastle this idyllic property offers a perfect balance of modern amenities & nature. Tastefully renovated with high-quality improvements. Roof, windows, siding, gutters & HVAC system have all been updated with energy-efficient features. Freshly painted, luxury vinyl tile, new carpet and oak hardwood floors. In addition recessed lighting & custom light fixtures have been added throughout. As you step inside the home you will notice the abundance of natural light filling every room. Thoughtfully designed windows offer stunning views of the historic covered bridge & the wooded surroundings. The gourmet kitchen offers custom Amish cabinets soft close doors & beautiful quartz countertops. New stainless Bosch appliances & 2 large pantries make this kitchen a culinary dream. The dining area flows effortlessly into the spacious living room making entertaining a breeze Main bathroom offers custom tile shower/ soaking bath combo, custom vanity w/ granite top & double sinks. The unique hallway guides you to the master bedroom which boasts beautiful hardwood floors & spacious sitting area. Additionally two generous bedrooms with hardwood floors round out the main floor Walking down the stunning wood staircase you will be greeted by a full daylight walkout basement. The lower level features 2 spacious bedrooms, full bath, living & great room & large laundry/hobby room. There is an attached 6-car tandem garage that is split into a 2-car garage & heated/ cooled, ventilated flex area w/hot & cold water & washer/dryer hookups. Plus a 30x40 two-story barn complete with a concrete floor water & electricity.

1815 W County Road 25 South, Greencastle

Listing courtesy of Carpenter, REALTORS®.

$459,900
2 Beds 2 Baths
THIS 15-ACRE MINI FARM WAYYYY OUT IN THE COUNTRY ABSOLUTELY HAS IT ALL!!! The completely renovated & updated 2-story home is the definition of modern farmhouse. Original refinished hardwood floors throughout, exposed brick, black trim, sleek light fixtures and the list goes on & on. Speaking of renovation, here's a list of what's NEW: vinyl siding, furnace & central A/C, vinyl, thermal, double pane windows throughout, cabinets, center island, granite countertops, tile backsplash & stainless steel appliances in Kitchen, hidden butler's pantry w/ barn door in DR, new vanities, granite countertops, custom tiled shower & toilets in both BAs, entire interior of home (walls & trim) freshly repainted & 2nd closet added in Master BR. The 1/2 BA was also added new to the home. The LR & DR are open to each other, and the 1/2 BA is just off the DR. The Master BR Suite is private & beautiful w/ double vanities, walk-in closet w/ stackable washer/dryer hook-up, plus an add'l. closet. Upstairs you'll find a HUGE 35x21 BR #2/Loft area. This used to be 2 separate BRs, but the Sellers opened it up for more space. It can easily be converted back to 2 separate BRs, if desired. Roof only 5 yrs. old, 200 amp. electrical & 3-inch foam insulation thorughout. The 50x60x12 Horse Barn features 6 stalls, hay feeders, 2nd story hay loft, 100 amp. electric & the metal roof is only 5 yrs. old. There is a small corn crib barn right next to it w/ a 2nd story hay loft, as well. The 40x48x16 Machine Shed is MASSIVE w/ 2 tall bays, 3 regular bays & 100 amp. electric. A 2-car carport, mini-barn w/ 2nd level, well house, grain bin & rustic horse shelter in the back pasture round out the outbuildings. There are several apple & pear trees on the property and plenty of woods for mushroom hunting. This property is country paradise...act fast!

5266 W County Road 175 N, Greencastle

Listing courtesy of Greene Realty, LLC.

$219,900
3 Beds 2 Baths
This 2,274 SF, 3 BR, 1.5 BA round home sitting on 1.54 acres is the DEFINITION OF ONE-OF-A-KIND!!! Built in 1988, this round home features a main level, plus full finished Basement, connected by a brick cylindrical pillar in the middle of the home. With curved walls, raised ceiling on the main level & uniquely shaped rooms, the architecture is incredible! The main level features open concept living w/ the LR, DR & Kitchen all connected. Stove, refrigerator & microwave all included. The Master BR is right next to the Full BA that has been recently updated w/ new flooring, vanity & light fixtures. BR #2 is currently under renovation. It has 3 closets, plus a laundry closet w/ washer & dryer included. The 1/2 BA in the hallway completes the main floor. The curved stairway at the end of the hallway leads down to the finished Basement w/ MASSIVE 26x24 Great Room w/ the chalkboard painted pillar anchoring the center of the room. BR #3 is 20x12 w/ sitting area, office area, plush carpet & walk-in closet. The 15x12 Bonus Room is currently staged as a Bedroom, but it can also serve as an Office, Playroom or whatever you need. There is plenty of room for parking w/ a 2-car detached Garage, plus add'l. 2-car concrete parking pad next to it. The Garage features an auto. door opener w/ keyless entry keypad, concrete floor, electric, workbenches & cabinets. (As an added bonus, both the riding lawnmower AND the push mower in the Garage are included to help you mow your new 1.54 acres!) The park-like backyard is HUGE w/ incredible landscaping and backs up to the woods. The outdoor living options are endless whether you admire your gorgeous front yard perennials & circular drive from the front deck, relax in your covered breezeway, swing in your hammock or swim in your above-ground pool. Roof only 4 years old, cool built-in bookshelves in the LR & the Breezeway connecting the house to the Garage is incredibly cool. Don't miss out on a home like no other!!!

3965 W County Road 125 S, Greencastle

Listing courtesy of Greene Realty, LLC.

$469,900
4 Beds 3 Baths
Ready for your forever home that is located in the quiet rural Putnam County area? This 4 BR 3 Full BA single story home w/ 3catt finished garage is situated on just over 9 acres of gorgeous countryside & calling your name. You will have the best of days waking up & sitting on your covered front porch taking in the waterfront view. The private fresh water lake has been maintained exquisitely, treated yearly, & there are ample amounts of fish, including striped bass & carp. If the home is where your heart is then you will be amazed when you see this layout. The kitchen, living room, & dining room were kept as an open concept so you can entertain or just enjoy the space without feeling boxed in. Another feature that's adds to the openness throughout are the pocket doors & the craftsmanship of how well they were installed is top notch. The MA bedroom & an additional bedroom both have a private full bathroom so whether you have a house guest needing a little privacy or you are in need of a mother-in-law quarters you are set. In 2019 this home took on a total makeover & nothing was left untouched. New Drywall, flooring, heating/cooling ductwork, windows, cedar siding, septic system & the list goes on. 40x20ft RV carport, 24x14 shed w/ dbl pane windows & insulation under flring that's ready to be transformed into a tiny house or a dream playhouse. The possibilities are endless w/ the acreage & ample sq footage.

2295 N County Road 250 W, Greencastle

Listing courtesy of Carpenter, REALTORS®.

Start Your Search

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2024 Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of REALTORS®

Greencastle Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for homes, condos, land and foreclosure properties available in Greencastle and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire. 

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood! 

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!